Our Officers And Board Members
2026 Chiefs
Jennifer Hartmann
Chief
Jennifer Hartmann is honored to serve as the 2026 Chief of Department and to continue a tradition of service that is deeply valued within the community. Jen joined Community Ambulance Company in 2010 and immediately obtained her EMT certification. From the beginning, she was inspired by the impact the organization has as neighbors helping neighbors. Her passion for service led her to expand her medical knowledge, becoming a paramedic and ultimately pursuing a career in nursing. Today, she holds a Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) and works professionally with critically ill patients, while remaining deeply committed to her role as a volunteer with Community Ambulance. Throughout her time as a volunteer, she has been recognized with numerous honors, including Member of the Year, Suffolk County Advanced Life Support Provider of the Year, Suffolk County RN of Excellence, and multiple Life Saving Awards.
Daniel Schappert
1st Assistant Chief
Dan has been a vital member of the emergency services community since 2008, currently serving as the 1st Assistant Chief at Community Ambulance Company. His ascent to this role followed valuable experiences as Captain from 2020-2023 and Lieutenant in 2019. Before joining CAC, Dan contributed significantly to the Port Jefferson Volunteer Ambulance, reflecting his deep-rooted commitment to aiding others. In addition to his leadership duties, Dan shares his knowledge as an instructor in EVOC, CEVO, and Communications. His expertise also extends to serving as an Emergency Services Dispatcher and an EMT for various Suffolk County agencies. Dan's academic pursuits in Technical Theatre and Automated Lighting and Stage Rigging at Suffolk County Community College highlight his diverse interests. Away from his professional responsibilities, Dan enjoys photography, hiking, and spending time with his dog, Norman.
Vincent Fattarusso
2nd Assistant Chief
Biography coming soon!
2026 Captains
Brendan Dargis
Brendan was a member of our Youth squad program in 2019 which sparked his interest in volunteering. As soon as he was able to, he enrolled in an EMT class and became our first 17 year old EMT at Community Ambulance Company. His older sister Kelsey (a life member of Community Ambulance Company), was a great role model in his life, and inspired him to volunteer and to make the community a better place. Brendan, now an EMT for 3 years, works in EMS for other local agencies in our area, as well as volunteers at Sayville Fire Department. Outside of EMS, Brendan is the owner of a landscaping company and is furthering his education at Farmingdale State College. He has additionally earned his Eagle Scout, loves to spend time with his family and friends, and loves going to the beach.
Alyson Sena
Alyson's journey with us began in November 2018, inspired by her older sister, who was also part of our team. After graduating from Bayport-Blue Point High School, Alyson had some extra time and wasn't quite sure where to direct her energies. Originally, she dreamt of a career working with animals and was pursuing a degree in marine biology. However, her sister encouraged her to try something new. From her very first ride-along, Alyson discovered a passion for emergency medicine. She was captivated by the sense of gratitude and the endless opportunities to learn as an EMT. Her dedication led her to work with multiple agencies, including a memorable stint as a beach EMT at Robert Moses State Park. Now a certified Paramedic, Alyson serves as an ALS provider across several agencies, driven by her desire to make a difference in people's lives.
Giavana Prucha
Back in 2014, Giavana first set foot in the quaint headquarters of Community Ambulance Company on Swayze Street, and since then, has continued to call Sayville home. Starting in the Youth Squad program, she quickly envisioned a career in service and knew she would dedicate her life to medicine. Over the years she has balanced squeezing in as many shifts on school breaks as possible, holding down the highly coveted overnight positions, and seizing every opportunity to expand her knowledge of pre-hospital care. This year, she looks forward to returning to oversee the same Youth Squad program that shaped her, while also focusing on training the membership at large. In August of 2023, Giavana began pursuing her doctorate in medicine. When she is not training members or coordinating chaos, you can find her spending time outdoors with one (or all!) of her three dogs.
Shane Leuly
Shane joined Community Ambulance Company after developing a strong interest in emergency services and community response. He began his career in emergency services with the Town of Brookhaven Division of Ocean Rescue as an Ocean Lifeguard gaining valuable experience in leadership and public safety. Shane became an EMT in 2021 and shortly after joined Community Ambulance Company wanting to help his community. Outside of CAC, Shane also holds a Bachelor of Arts in History from Southern New Hampshire University and he proudly serves as a member of the Bayport Fire Department as a volunteer firefighter and continues to work for the Town of Brookhaven in their Division of Ocean Rescue.
2026 Lieutenants
Connor Cutolo
Lieutenant
Connor joined Community in 2022 and has served not only as a member but became a crew chief in 2025 ensuring crews and ambulances were ready to assist the public as needed wherever and whenever. Connor has been an EMT for 3 years and has continued to complete various trainings and classes to further his skills and knowledge. As well Connor has been a member of the Sayville Fire Department since 2021. He is incredibly grateful and excited for the opportunity to be a lieutenant and looks forward to a good year helping the members of the department and the community.
Matthew Wheeler
Lieutenant
Matthew joined Community Ambulance in 2021 as a paramedic and quickly demonstrated a strong commitment to both patient care and leadership. While serving with Community Ambulance, he also held the position of Assistant Chief with the Wyandanch-Wheatley Heights Ambulance Corporation. In 2023, Matthew relocated to Sayville and became an active volunteer member who regularly answers calls and assists with training. Matthew brings a wealth of knowledge, experience, and dedication to the officer ranks and looks forward to continuing to grow and serve within his community. In addition to his volunteer role, Matthew works as a career paramedic with the Nassau County Police Department.
Samantha O'Donnell
Lieutenant
Samantha O'Donnell began her journey with the Community Ambulance Company as a member of the Youth Squad in April 2023 at the age of 16. Through dedication and hard work, she advanced to Probationary Member and then to Regular Member in November 2024. In May 2025, Sam took on a leadership role teaching the Youth Squad program and she currently serves as the Youth Squad Director. In addition to her role with the ambulance company, Sam has been a Volunteer Firefighter with the West Sayville Fire Department since June 2023. Sam is currently working in EMS at a neighboring agency, while also being in college to pursue her paramedic certification, with the goal of one day becoming a flight medic.
Paige Hall
Lieutenant
Paige joined Community Ambulance during her senior year at Stony Brook University, where she earned a degree in Psychology. Unsure whether she wanted to pursue nursing school, she became an EMT to remain involved in the medical field. It didn't take long for her to fall in love with life on the ambulance and with being a member of the Community Ambulance family. Recognized as one of CAC's Top 10 Responders for 2025, Paige consistently dedicates her spare time to supporting the organization and is always looking for new ways to get involved. Outside of CAC, Paige can usually be found at the barn spending time with her horse, Brooklyn, or adventuring with her dog, Blu.
Brian Noack
Lieutenant
Brian Noack has been involved with Community Ambulance since around 2009, first serving as Chaplain of the Company. Over the last two years, he has obtained his EMT card and has been riding as a full member. He is looking to continue to grow in his EMS knowledge and serve in the various communities of our area. He also currently serves St. John's Lutheran in Sayville full time as pastor.
Kevin Campbell
Lieutenant
Kevin serves as a dedicated lieutenant driven by a lifelong commitment to helping others in need. Growing up around first responders—most notably his mother—instilled in him a deep respect for service and inspired his path into emergency care. With two years of experience as an EMT, Kevin brings both skill and compassion to every situation he encounters. He is currently continuing his education to further advance his medical knowledge. Outside of his duties, Kevin enjoys attending Mets games, skiing, spending time outdoors, and being around friends and family.
2026 Operational Secretary
Elizabeth Kiernan
Lizzie's journey started at a young age, watching her grandfather tell stories of being a firefighter in New York City. In 2022 she finished up class and immediately decided to start riding at Community Ambulance Company. With all the wonderful experience she gained over the past three going on four years, she had gotten a job with Northwell Health EMS, furthering her experience with emergency services. All while still continuing college at Farmingdale State College and receiving a certification in phlebotomy at BOCES. She is excited and dedicated to take on this position as operational secretary and continue to serve her community.
2026 Community Ambulance Company Board
Dennis Kelly
President
Dennis P. Kelly, Jr. has been a cornerstone of Community Ambulance since July 25, 1973, marking over half a century of unwavering dedication and service. His journey with the organization is a testament to his selflessness, leadership, and commitment to the community. Dennis has held numerous leadership roles, most notably serving as Chief during the transformative decades of the 1980s, 1990s, and into the new millennium. In 2003, Dennis was honored by his peers with an ambulance dedicated in his name. Throughout recent years, Dennis has continued to showcase his leadership by addressing unprecedented challenges posed by the pandemic and fostering stronger relationships within the organization. As a mentor and role model, he has inspired countless volunteers, instilling in them the values of service and compassion that are the hallmark of Community Ambulance.
Shawn Votino
Vice President
Biography coming soon!
Michael Duffy
Director
Mike Duffy began his journey with Community Ambulance Company in August 2005, quickly earning his EMT certificate the following year. Holding a Bachelor's degree in History from Adelphi, Mike's sense of duty led him to serve as a Lieutenant with the company in 2009. That same year marked another milestone for him as he joined the ranks of the NYPD. Juggling the responsibilities of a full-time police officer, Mike impressively secured a position as a top ten responder on three occasions. He once again took on the role of Lieutenant for Community Ambulance in 2017 and 2018. In his professional life, Mike continues to serve and protect as a Narcotics Detective with the NYPD.
Keri White
Director
Keri joined Community Ambulance in January of 2018. Her motivation has always been rooted in her profound interest in healthcare and a heartfelt commitment to helping others during critical moments. Shortly after joining, Keri was honored as Member of the Year for 2019. After taking on a more active role in EMS by working as an EMT full time, Keri decided to expand her medical knowledge by becoming an Advanced Life Support provider and now works full time as a Paramedic at neighboring agencies. In 2022, she experienced the loss of her mother to pancreatic cancer. This poignant experience has fueled Keri's determination to hopefully pursue a career in nursing with a focus in oncology.
Karen Scheck
Secretary
Biography coming soon!
Marc MacDonell
Treasurer
Marc embarked on his journey with Community Ambulance Company in April 1977. He swiftly achieved his EMT status and ascended the organizational ranks. By 1979, he was appointed Crew Chief of his duty shift, a role he passionately served in for over 25 years. His leadership prowess was recognized in 1984 when he was elected to the Board of Directors. By 1993, he took on the role of Treasurer, a position he continues to uphold. Between 2011 and 2014, Marc played a pivotal role in leading the committee responsible for designing and inaugurating the new ambulance headquarters, which was unveiled in October 2014. On a personal note, he met his beloved wife, MaryAnn, at the company. Now, with a marriage spanning 37 years, their legacy continues as their children, Colleen and James, are active members.